How is that possible? Well it happens all the time, especially in that golden 18-49 demographic. Here is a chart of the 20 highest rated but canceled broadcast shows of 2013-2014 in that magic 18-49 demographic.
Robin Williams return to the small screen brought some bittersweet ratings. His show Crazy Ones was number 1 on the list with a 2.7 rating in the key 18-49 demographic, but it was still canceled.
It tied with FOX’s Almost Human which took up space on my DVR and I never watched a single episode. I usually watch anything with Karl Urban in it. Oh well.
But that 18-49 demo isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be. For example, FOX’s Bones‘ runs around a 2.4 but it’s an enduring show that has proven its value to the network.
The Mentalist on CBS is another show earning a 2.0 but it also survived the cut. So it’s easy to say that numbers aren’t the only thing taken into consideration when shows are on the chopping block.
Here’s a list of what’s returning this month (June):
Longmire (Season 3) — A&E (June 2)
Mistresses (Season 2) — ABC (June 2)
Major Crimes (Season 3) — TNT (June 9)
Royal Pains (Season 6) — USA Network (June 10)
Graceland (Season 2) — USA Network (June 11)
Suits (Season 4) — USA Network (June 11)
Dog and Beth: On the Hunt (Season 2) — CMT (June 14)
Perception (Season 3) — TNT (June 17)
Rizzoli & Isles (Season 5) — TNT (June 17)
Rookie Blue (Season 5) — ABC (June 19)
Defiance (Season 2) — Syfy (June 19)
Wipeout (Season 7) — ABC (June 22)
True Blood (Season 7; final season) — HBO (June 22)
Falling Skies (Season 4) — TNT (June 22)
Teen Wolf (Season 4) — MTV (June 23)
Covert Affairs (Season 5) — USA Network (June 24)
Big Brother (Season 16) — CBS (June 25)
Unforgettable (Season 3) — CBS (June 29)
Last Tango in Halifax (Season 2) — PBS (June 29)
Under the Dome (Season 2) — CBS (June 30)
Some canceled shows I know of include Once Upon a Time in Wonderland and Mind Games (ABC) and Greg Kinnear’s Rake (FOX) which seemed to end before it even began.